So the question we have been answering via this blog and our presentation has been: How much has freedom of information legislation improved journalists’ access to official public sources?
What we think
I think I speak for Speak Out (as it were) when I say we all felt Freedom of Information legislation in the UK has its limitations. The fuss MPs have made over disclosing their expenses shows how politicians are often less than willing to comply with the spirit of the FoI legislation if it is not in their interest. The apparent downward trend in the success of FOI requests in the US especially under George W Bush (as signposted by Ciara here) are another depressing reminder of this. Even public service organisations like the BBC are not averse to making it hard for journalists to gain access to information to which they are entitled. I highlighted this earlier on the blog and Ciara’s research on the Balen report also supports this thesis.
However, Hannah found a very interesting case where it could be argued FoI requests alerted members of the public to the possible danger of absconded prisoners.
What others think
When we spoke to other journalists, they seemed to share our frustrations. Local journalist Tim Hubbard (BBC Radio Cornwall) felt that FoI legislation was not the ‘panacea’ to cure the culture of secrecy in public authorities. Meanwhile, David Leigh, a nationally known and respected Guardian journalist) has used FoI requests less as time has passed since the legislation was enacted. He pointed out that the list of exceptions can be and are used to obstruct the release of information to journalists.
So how useful?
Well, it is surely better to have FoI than nothing at all, especially in a country where open government is not exactly an accepted norm.
But David Leigh says the Act needs to be toughened up in the same way that the US FoI legislation was after the Watergate scandal, and I agree. If the legislation is to help journalists to get at the truth behind government press releases – and those of other public authorities – the culture needs to change.
Amy Pollock